How swell one might imagine that it is to have a high-autonomy and well-paid postdoc at Harvard, it is even more swell to have this and still have demography library privileges at the University of Wisconsin. I needed a single page from the American Economic Review that was not part of the online-accessible collection. It was also unclear whether that particular print issue of the journal was going to be at either the undergraduate or graduate libraries (so it would be hit-or-miss to walk over hunting for it). I e-mailed the UW demography library, and had a pdf of the page within an hour.
(For those who've followed my reproducibility-standards-saga, the page in question was the editorial statement (by Ben Bernanke, successor to Alan Greenspan at the Federal Researve) indicating that the McCullough and Vinod problems that I quoted yesterday was indeed the reason for AER stepping up its policy [the principle of the policy existed, the change was active enforcement by requiring actual submission of materials to the Editors to be posted].)
Note also: Chris has his own ideas about possible expansion of the reproducibility principles to other domains.
You sort'a look like Scott McClellan .........
ReplyDeleteI do not sort of look like Scott McClellan. Take it back.
ReplyDeleteThis is like a social movement for nerds. A nerd revolution.
ReplyDeleteIt seems so basic and common-sensical: Share the darn code and nobody gets hurt!
I guess secretly I want to see big name a#*hole(s) be publicly shamed in a major sociology journal when no one can reproduce his/her/their results.
I think I will deposit data and code from all my stuff at that ICPSR archive you mentioned.
... reeling in McClellan
ReplyDelete